VALLEJO – Vallejo tenants’ rights groups urged the City Council to move forward with a package of ordinances designed to protect tenants from eviction and rising rents while property owners raised economic concerns and argued for alternative approaches on Tuesday.
The discussion took place during an update on the city staff’s progress toward developing renter protection ordinances for rent control, just cause evictions, tenant anti-harassment anti-coercion measures and legal support programs that ensure tenants have access to legal counsel for housing disputes.
A group of tenant’s rights and legal organizations argued that the rising cost of rent has outpaced wages in Vallejo. They cited statistics indicating that, of all the Bay Area cities, Vallejo has the highest percentage of residents who pay 30% or more of their income toward rent. The tenants groups also pointed to high rates of eviction in Solano County compared to other Bay Area counties and said three of the four zip codes with the highest lockout rates are located in Vallejo.
“The burden falls hardest on Black, Latinx, and mixed-race households—more than half of whom are cost-burdened—according to the city’s own Housing Element.” civil rights law firm Public Advocates said in a statement supporting advancement of the tenant protections.
But property owners argue that tenant protections would discourage investment in Vallejo and reduce the overall housing supply, further impacting the cost of housing.
The city has been seeking to introduce a renter’s protection ordinance for the last few years. Vallejo’s housing element, a state mandated plan to meet housing needs, requires the City Council to consider regulations to improve housing stability for the city’s renters.
California has a statewide renter protection law, the Tenant Protection Act of 2019, which provides basic just cause limitations on evictions but includes a number of exceptions and does not provide legal services for tenants. The law limits rent increases to 5% a year plus the percent that the cost of living changes or 10%, whichever is lower.
Legal Services of Northern California managing attorney Shannon McCaffrey said Tuesday that the existing tenant protections under state law are inadequate.
“If someone's monthly rent was $1,500 per month in 2022, it could have legally been raised to $2,110 by this year.” McCaffrey said. “That is over $600 per month or a 41% increase from the $1,500 per month rate in 2022 and it is legal under the statewide protections.”
“That is not sufficient to prevent Vallejo residents from being displaced,” McCaffrey said.
The Vallejo Housing Justice Coalition and Urban Habitat published a report in July that surveyed 319 Vallejo residents, and found that many of them struggled with rent increases and substandard conditions. According to the report, 75% of respondents supported rent control and 80% supported just cause eviction protections and a tenant’s right to counsel program.
In September, the Vallejo Housing Justice Coalition provided the city with recommendations for a tenant protections package that is significantly stronger than the state law. The organization recommended just cause eviction protections covering all housing types without exceptions and recommended protecting tenants from day one as opposed to state law, which does not cover tenants who have lived in a home for less than a year.
It also recommended stronger rent control that would cap rent increases at 60% of the Consumer Price Index or 2.5%, whichever is less.
The council held a contentious study session on the renter protection proposals on Sept. 30 which revealed strong frustrations and a deep divide between landlords and tenants.
“We feel it's critically important that everything be done to stem or stop the rising cost of housing, so we don't birth a new crowd of homeless to stack upon the existing homeless we have in Vallejo already,” Vallejo Homeless Union President Shawn O’Mally, said.
Dana Seymour, a local property owner and real estate broker said that landlords are having a rough time as it is without any more rules and regulations and fees and bureaucracy.
“All too often by the time I pay all the bills and absorb the losses of rental property ownership, I end up losing money,” Seymour said. “All this bureaucracy and nonsense and homeless this and that. You're coddling the homeless. It's not helping. It's making it worse. These are making it attractive to be homeless. People need to work and take care of their bills themselves instead of sucking on the city tit all the time. I'm sick of it.”
Meanwhile, several property owners said that smaller landlords who offer reasonable rents and comply with existing housing standards would be forced out by the tenant protections only to be replaced by large corporate landholders that can afford a legal team to defend abusive practices.
Vallejo Planning Manager Hector Rojas said that according to the city’s housing element, of the 18,709 renter-occupied households in Vallejo, 10,463 of those are cost-burdened or spend at least 30% of their household income on housing. That figure includes 5,875 severely cost-burdened households, which spent at least 50% of their income on housing, he said.
Rojas noted that a recent San Francisco Chronicle report found that 71% of Vallejo renters are cost-burdened, the highest percentage of all the Bay Area cities. Rojas said that the Chronicle analysis is more recent and uses a different methodology so it cannot be directly compared to the city's housing element data.
“But these two data points are important,” Rojas said. “Because the need for rental protections, the number of households potentially affected and the city's administrative workload all depend on Vallejo's housing conditions and the coverage rules that the council might ultimately consider for these protections.”
According to Rojas, local tenant protection measures can involve significant costs related to enforcement, administrative hearings, and legal support. In other cities, annual program costs range from $615,000 to $7.5 million.
Rojas said the cities of Hayward and Richmond provided examples that were comparable to the number of units that a city of Vallejo program would need to cover. Hayward offered a lower level of service, requiring 3.5 full time employees to cover 11,580 units at an annual cost of $642,000. Richmond offered more comprehensive service requiring 14 full time employees to cover 18,000 units at a cost of $3 million.
Cities often charge property owners a fee to recover the cost of administering the renter protection programs. Rojas said those fees range from $66 per unit to $290 per unit and some ordinances allow property owners to pass those costs on to renters.
The City Council voted to conduct a market and feasibility study to provide information specific to Vallejo that would allow city staff to estimate costs and the number of full time employees that would be required to administer the tenant protections.
But tenants groups have grown frustrated with the pace of the efforts. In October, Legal Services of Northern California and two other public service law organizations sent a letter to the city demanding it present a proposal for renter protections to the City Council by Dec. 8 or the organizations would consider legal action.
The letter stated that the housing element represents a legally binding commitment under state law and the city is over a year behind on its pledge to bring a renter protection proposal before the council.
The letter pointed out that at the study session, Vallejo City Attorney Veronica Nebb said that her staff has capacity and expertise to draft the proposed ordinances “in whatever timeframe the Council would like.”
On Tuesday, landlords and renters’ groups once again passionately argued for or against the protections.
Investor Peter Balas presented a report to the City Council as a representative of an organization he called the Vallejo Rental Property Owners Coalition. Balas agreed that Vallejo has a housing affordability problem but said the property owners’ report examines whether additional rent control will meaningfully solve it and at what costs.
The report identified a series of questions that Balas said the group would like the market and feasibility study to address, including what benefits that the local rent control measures would provide to tenants beyond state law protections and how the local tenant protections would affect investment, maintenance, property values, and housing supply. It also asked whether the city has the resources to administer the program along with existing priorities and suggested the city identify alternative approaches that could address underlying causes of housing instability.
Balas said that in just ten days of outreach, the group’s report received support from 36 rental property owners representing 490 rental units and more than $170 million in Vallejo real estate. He said that the report is also endorsed by the Solano Association of Realtors and the Apartment Owners Association of California.
It was not clear how the council may ultimately proceed. Councilmember Helen-Marie Gordon said, “Even as I sit on this dias, my biggest fear is always being evicted. Not that that is a current situation, but I still have suffered from PTSD from it.”
Gordon said that she would like to see the renter protections approved sooner rather than later. She acknowledged there are property owners who don't take advantage of renters but said, “if you have no bad intentions, what's wrong with having renter protection and housing stability measures?”
Mayor Andrea Sorse said that the council needs to carefully vet the ordinances to ensure that they do not cause unintended harm to vulnerable residents. She asked the city staff to bring information back to the council about what it would take to put a temporary rent freeze in place while the city works to develop the ordinances.
Independent local news depends on you
The Vallejo Sun is supported by readers who value reliable, in-depth local news. Your support helps us continue investigating important issues and keeping Vallejo informed.
Become a member today- Housing
- government
- Vallejo
- Vallejo City Council
- Vallejo City Hall
- Vallejo Housing Justice Coalition
- Public Advocates
- Tenant Protection Act
- Shannon McCaffrey
- Urban Habitat
- Shawn O'Mally
- Dana Seymour
- Hector Rojas
- Veronica Nebb
- Peter Balas
- Helen-Marie Gordon
- Andrea Sorce
Ryan Geller
Ryan Geller writes about transitions in food, health, housing, environment, and agriculture.
follow me :
