VALLEJO – The city of Vallejo released a redacted independent investigator’s report Thursday regarding a former senior city employee’s complaints that Mayor Andrea Sorce had interfered with the employee’s duties and sought to have the employee terminated.
The City Council rejected a resolution to condemn Sorce last week for alleged conduct related to interactions with city employees and attempts to improperly influence decisions of city staff. The resolution did not provide details about the alleged misconduct, but the council voted to release a redacted version of an independent investigation that led city officials and an outside law firm to bring the condemnation resolution before the council.
According to Attorney Douglas Ropel, the fact-finding investigation was in progress from July 2025 to July 2026.
The report consists of claims by one former senior city employee who alleged that Sorce engaged in a campaign of retribution based on her perception that the employee played a role in the termination of former city special advisor Slater Matzke, who is Sorce’s husband. The claims include allegations that Sorce attempted to influence another senior level city employee to fire the primary claimant.
Karen Herz, a workplace investigator with the firm Impartial Investigations, conducted a series of interviews with councilmembers and city employees and examined relevant city communications to produce the 42-page report. The investigator found that the evidence substantiated several of the employee’s claims.
Names of city staff are redacted in the report, however details provided in the report related to the claimant’s position and length of employment with the city match former Assistant City Manager Gillian Haen, who is now the city manager for the city of Chico. Details in the report related to the senior level employee that Sorce allegedly attempted to influence match former City Manager Andrew Murray.
Haen herself faced allegations of misconduct in a lawsuit by former city spokesperson Christina Lee last year alleging unethical and potentially illegal actions by Haen, such as directing a subordinate to delete text messages in violation of the California Public Records Act.
Five of the seven claims against Sorce are listed as substantiated in the report. The first substantiated claim is that Sorce sought Haen’s termination and urged Murray to fire her. Herz found the first part of this claim to be substantiated. However, the second part, an allegation that Murray acted on Sorce’s suggestion, Herz found to be unsubstantiated because Murray already wanted to fire Haen before Sorce was elected Mayor.
The investigator also substantiated claims that Sorce influenced a decision not to appoint Haen as acting city manager during Murray’s absence, that Sorce wrongfully and publicly accused a city staff member of violating California open meeting law and that a senior level employee failed to intervene on the staff member’s behalf.
The two final substantiated claims are that Sorce influenced the reassignment of Haen’s homelessness-related duties and that Sorce excluded her from meetings related to development on Mare Island.
The unsubstantiated claims include the allegation that Sorce influenced Murray to deny Haen’s request to be paid for vacation time she was unable to use and Haen’s allegation that she was reprimanded for a memo criticizing the council in retaliation for her other complaints.
Councilmembers Charles Palmeres, Peter Bregenzer, Diosdado “JR” Matulac and Helen-Marie Gordon all provided Herz with accounts that generally supported Haen’s allegations. Accounts from city employees as well as city documents and emails were also used as evidence to substantiate the claims.
Palmares said that Sorce pushed to exclude Haen from Mare Island development meetings, which deprived the meeting participants of Haen’s valuable institutional knowledge.
Bregenzer strongly criticized Sorce, saying that she campaigned on transparency but as mayor that translated to being overly critical of staff so they appeared incompetent in public. He characterized Sorce’s behavior toward Haen as a ”witch hunt."
According to the report, Bregenzer said he defended Haen’s work on redeveloping the Mare Island agreement, but Sorce “‘instantly’ shut him down, telling him that she is happy to have him hear her husband's side of the story.”
Matulac said that he witnessed Sorce telling Haen that she did a poor job. He said that there may have been some truth to that but Sorce was "basically belittling or demeaning.”
According to Haen’s account in the report, Matulac suggested she consider legal action against the city due to Sorce’s behavior. Matulac said that he could not recall making such a statement. Haen’s account also indicated that Bregenzer told her that he was surprised she had not sued the city over Sorce’s behavior.
Bregenzer denied saying that, but admitted that he had made similar statements to other councilmembers.
The report states that Gordon provided her account "unprompted by the investigator.” According to the report, Gordon said that in both open and closed council meeting sessions, Sorce made comments that she wanted to get rid of Haen and that Sorce initially used cost as her rationale, but later started attacking the claimant's work and belittling her integrity.
One of the unsubstantiated claims involved a memo which Haen drafted and sent to the City Council. The memo sought to correct information that the council had provided to the public related to the staff’s work on the Broadway project.
“This misinformation that staff is inexperienced began with the Broadway project was put into the MRG Report falsely,” the memo stated. “The story has continued to spread through the newspaper, at multiple public meetings, and in the media. The misrepresentation must stop being regurgitated as it is untrue and it is damaging to staff. On January 8, 2025, staff formally clarified the misrepresentation of the MRG report but no correction has been shared to date.”
According to the report, Murray found the language in the memo to be unprofessional but he allowed a significant amount of time to pass before reprimanding Haen. Haen alleged that the reprimand was really a form of retaliation for her other complaints. Herz found Murray's delay to be concerning but determined that the reprimand was not retaliation.
Councilmembers Tonia Lediju and Alexander Matias do not appear on the report’s list of witnesses. Herz asked to interview Sorce but she declined with the understanding that the investigation would be conducted without her input.
Independent local news depends on you
The Vallejo Sun is supported by readers who value reliable, in-depth local news. Your support helps us continue investigating important issues and keeping Vallejo informed.
Become a member today- government
- Vallejo
- Vallejo City Council
- Vallejo City Hall
- Andrew Murray
- Andrea Sorce
- Gillian Haen
- Slater Matzke
- Karen Herz
- Impartial Investigation
- Peter Bregenzer
- Diosdado “J.R.” Matulac
- Helen-Marie Gordon
- Charles Palmares
Ryan Geller
Ryan Geller writes about transitions in food, health, housing, environment, and agriculture.
follow me :
